Plate-fin radiators consist of two main assemblies: the core and external accessories. The core, the key component for vacuum brazing, is formed by stacking and assembling separator plates, fins, sealing strips and guide fins, followed by integral vacuum brazing. Under normal qualified conditions, the extruded brazing filler metal covers approximately 1/3 of the sealing strip. The anomaly observed in this case is full coverage of the sealing strip by filler metal, accompanied by helium leak test failure.
Description of Phenomenon
After vacuum brazing, the spreading of brazing filler metal on the sealing strip far exceeds the control limit (specification: ≤ 1/3 of the sealing strip width). The filler metal nearly covers the entire sealing strip. On the bonding interface of the sealing strip, filler metal shows depletion in some areas and local accumulation, resulting in failure of the helium leak test.
I. Filler Metal Supply and Cladding of Base Material (Material Side)
- The cladding thickness of fins / separator plates is out of tolerance, leading to excessive total filler metal. Limited accommodation space is available after melting; surplus filler metal continuously spreads outward, exceeding the normal limit of 1/3 and covering the entire sealing strip.
- Poor surface cleaning of base material with residual rolling oil and grease, as well as uneven removal of oxide film, results in abnormal interfacial wettability and irregular widespread flow of filler metal.
- Composition fluctuation of 4004 cladding widens the solid-liquid phase range. The filler metal exhibits excessively high fluidity at elevated temperature and tends to spread outward more easily.
II. Brazing Temperature Profile (Most Common Root Cause)
- Excessive peak temperature and prolonged high-temperature holding time: the fluidity of filler metal increases markedly, and the capillary spreading distance extends. The filler spreads from the normal 1/3 coverage to fully cover the sealing strip. Meanwhile, excessive flow depletes filler metal at the bonding interface and results in lack of fusion.
- Large temperature gradient across the core leads to local overheating at the sealing strip area, where filler metal overflows preferentially in large quantity.
- Too slow heating rate causes prolonged residence within the solid-liquid two-phase region, so the filler metal slowly spreads prematurely.
III. Assembly, Weight Loading and Sealing Strip Structure (Assembly Process Factors)
- Excessive assembly clearance and poor contact: large gaps between separator plates and sealing strips enhance capillary force, driving continuous outward migration of filler metal beyond the 1/3 control limit. Uneven clearance also leads to inconsistent filler distribution, i.e. insufficient filler on one side and full coverage on the other.
- Improper loading pressure: insufficient pressure results in large gaps and extrudes filler metal outward. Excessive pressure squeezes molten filler metal directly onto the surface of the sealing strip. Uneven pressure distribution causes massive local accumulation of filler metal.
- The sealing strip has no retaining step or limiting structure for filler metal. Without a blocking boundary, the filler metal spreads outward without restriction.
IV. Vacuum Environment inside the Furnace Insufficient vacuum level and high dew point lead to inconsistent breakdown of oxide films. Preferential wetting occurs in areas with thin oxide films, and filler metal flows directionally in large quantities toward the sealing strip surface, resulting in local full coverage.
✅ Mechanism from Filler Metal Full Coverage on Sealing Strip to Leakage (Key Section)
- Normal condition: A small amount of filler metal overflows onto 1/3 of the sealing strip. Sufficient filler metal remains at the bonding interface to form a continuous and dense brazed joint.
- Abnormal condition: A large volume of filler metal migrates away and covers the sealing strip. The bonding interface between sealing strip and separator plate suffers insufficient filler supply, giving rise to discontinuous brazed seams and lack-of-fusion gaps. The thick accumulated filler metal shrinks during cooling and forms shrinkage cavities, shrinkage porosity and microcracks, which eventually cause helium leak test failure.
V. Corrective Actions
- Verify cladding thickness and control the total allowance of filler metal to stabilize filler supply.
- Calibrate furnace temperature by temperature measurement, appropriately reduce the peak temperature and shorten the high-temperature holding time to control filler fluidity, and stabilize the spreading extent within 1/3 of the sealing strip width.
- Standardize assembly clearance and evenly adjust loading pressure. Add retaining steps on sealing strips to limit the outward spreading distance of filler metal.
- Strengthen control over alkaline / acid pickling to ensure clean workpiece surfaces; stabilize furnace vacuum and dew point indicators.
- Establish visual acceptance criteria for filler spreading on first articles: release is permitted only when filler coverage does not exceed 1/3 of the sealing strip width.
